Content may contain affiliate links. When you shop the links, I receive a small commission at no cost to you. Thank you for supporting my small business.

Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray (HC-165) is undoubtedly one of my all-time favorite blue-gray paint colors. Whether it’s adding sophistication to kitchen cabinets, creating a serene backdrop in a living room, or offering a fresh, modern look on accent walls, it’s the perfect color that harmonizes with both warm and cool color schemes.

This in-depth paint color review will delve into why Boothbay Gray is a great choice for various applications, from interior paint projects to exterior facades, and how it complements different shades of decor.

Kitchen with white perimeter cabinets and Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray island.

What Color is Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray?

Boothbay Gray is a medium blue-gray paint color, that also showcases a blue-green undertone, making it a gorgeous color for spaces that need a pop of color.

This blue-gray color has the strong gray undertones needed for it to adapt under various lighting conditions, showing off its range from a neutral gray to a more pronounced blue color in rooms filled with a lot of natural light, such as south-facing rooms. At times, it can also show the tiniest bit of green, especially with warm south-facing light.

Whether it looks more gray, more blue, or you notice the blue-green undertone depends entirely on the lighting conditions of your room, making it a great choice for north-facing rooms and east-facing rooms alike. For the most part, it will present itself as a blue-gray color.

butler's pantry with Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray cabinets and white countertops.

What is The Light Reflectance Value (LRV) of Boothbay Gray?

Boothbay Gray’s LRV stands at 43. Its LRV places it in the category of medium tones, making it a timeless color with enough depth to add character yet light enough to not overpower a space.

What is LRV? It stands for Light Reflectance Value and it’s basically a scale of how much light a paint color reflects, with 0 being absolute black and 100 being absolute white. You can read more about LRV in paint colors and how it can help you pick the right paint color for your room.

Small bathroom with a vanity painted Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray.

Is BM Boothbay Gray a Warm or Cool Color?

With its cool blue undertones, Boothbay Gray leans towards the cooler end of the spectrum, although its blue-green undertone adds a touch of warmth, making it a great neutral gray that can seamlessly integrate into various color palettes, especially when looking for a paint color choice that brings a calming effect to a master bedroom or a refreshing feel to a laundry room.

Don’t Forget…

Don’t forget – no matter what you’ve read or photos you’ve seen online, it’s really important to sample paint colors in your home before committing!

Samplize provides real paint samples that are easy to move around your home, and cheaper than buying a gazillion paint pots! It’s the only way I buy paint samples.

What Are The Undertones of Boothbay Gray?

Boothbay Gray’s blue-gray color undertone as well as subtle green undertones offer a great option for those seeking complexity and depth in their interior paint choices.

These undertones are particularly effective in providing a tranquil atmosphere, making it a great color for living room walls or as an accent color in a dining room. These undertones also make Boothbay Gray a versatile choice as a color that can bridge the gap between cool and warm color schemes.

BM Boothbay Gray vs Other Paint Colors

When comparing Boothbay Gray to other best paint colors, like Benjamin Moore Mount Saint Anne or Gray Owl, its strong blue undertones and medium blue-gray hue set it apart.

Bedroom with picture frame molding painted Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray. There's a wood nightstand and beige upholstered bed.

Where Should You Use BM Boothbay Gray?

The possibilities are endless when it comes to incorporating Boothbay Gray into your home decor. Whether it’s in the serene ambiance of a bathroom or the productivity-enhancing atmosphere of a home office, this versatile color is sure to elevate any space it graces.

Butler's pantry with Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray cabinets, brass hardware and white countertops.
This is the same pantry as earlier, but the cabinets look darker and grayer with less sunlight hitting them.

I particularly like it as a cabinet color, whether that be for a pantry (above), a laundry room or a kitchen island.

Boothbay Gray is not just a good interior color, either. It makes a really nice choice for a lighter blue gray color for any home’s exterior.

Classic dormered Cape Cod style house painted Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray.

BM Boothbay Gray vs BM Gray Owl

side by side swatch of Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray versus Gray Owl.

Benjamin Moore’s Boothbay Gray (LRV 44) and Gray Owl (LRV 65) offer distinct choices for those seeking gray paint colors.

Boothbay Gray is a medium, cool blue-gray that adds depth and serenity to a space, making it ideal for creating a calming atmosphere. Gray Owl, with its higher LRV, is a lighter gray that can subtly shift to reveal green undertones, enhancing the brightness and versatility of a room.

The key differences lie in their undertones and difference in LRV, with Boothbay Gray providing a cooler, more stable appearance, and Gray Owl offering a lighter, more adaptable backdrop that changes with the light.

BM Boothbay Gray vs BM Mount Saint Anne

side by side swatch of Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray versus Mount Saint Anne.

Boothbay Gray and Mount Saint Anne by Benjamin Moore are two cool, but very different colors. Boothbay Gray, with an LRV of 44, is a soft, calm blue-gray that’s great for making rooms feel peaceful. Mount Saint Anne is a bit darker, with an LRV of 42, and blends blue with a touch of green, giving it a rich, sophisticated vibe.It’s perfect for making a bold statement or creating cozy spots.

Essentially, if you’re after a gentle, serene look, go for Boothbay Gray. If you prefer something with a bit more depth and elegance, Mount Saint Anne is your color.

BM Boothbay Gray vs BM Solitude

side by side comparison swatch of Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray vs Benjamin Moore Solitude.

Solitude is more of a light blue than a true gray. It’s quite soft and gives off a calm vibe, which makes it great for creating a relaxing space. It’s noticeably bluer than Boothbay Gray, especially when the sun hits it, making the room feel serene and peaceful. Solitude has an LRV of around 38, making it slightly darker than Boothbay Gray which has an LRV of 44.

The Sherwin Williams Color Equivalent

side by side swatch of BM Boothbay Gray and SW Mineral Deposit.

While there’s no exact match for Boothbay Gray in the Sherwin Williams palette, Mineral Deposit (SW 7652) comes close with its similar cool-toned nature and depth of color.


Absolutely! Boothbay Gray’s depth and richness make it a fantastic choice for exterior applications, adding a touch of sophistication to any home’s facade.

For a classic and timeless look, consider pairing Boothbay Gray with crisp whites such as Benjamin Moore’s Chantilly Lace or Sherwin Williams Pure White. These clean white trim colors beautifully complement Boothbay Gray’s cool undertones, creating a cohesive and elegant aesthetic.

When it comes to creating harmonious color palettes, consider pairing BM Boothbay Gray with complementary hues such as Stonington Gray, White Wisp, or Pearl River. These colors work seamlessly together, creating a cohesive and inviting atmosphere in any space.

Final Thoughts

Small office with BM Boothbay Gray walls, white trim and a white oak desk.

Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray is a true gem in the world of paint colors, and its becoming one of Benjamin Moore’s most popular blue gray paint colors for good reason.

Its unique blend of blue and gray tones creates a calming and sophisticated ambiance in any space. Whether used as an interior or exterior paint color, Boothbay Gray is sure to elevate your home’s look and feel.

So there you have it! Benjamin Moore Boothbay Gray is a must-have for anyone looking to add a touch of elegance and tranquility to their living space. Don’t just take my word for it—grab a paint sample and see for yourself the magic of Boothbay Gray!

Looking for more? Follow me on social media for lots more home decor & DIY content!

Pinterest | Instagram | Facebook | LTK

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *