Choosing the perfect kitchen backsplash can be a daunting task, but with some careful consideration, you can find a tile that will look great for years to come. The right tile can have a significant impact on the overall design of your kitchen.

carrara marble backsplash and oak floating shelf

Whether you prefer timeless styles like marble and subway tile, or want something really on trend like the popular hand crafted and glazed Moroccan tiles known as Zellige, there’s something out there for every budget and style.

Ready to figure out how to choose to choose a backsplash that’s right for your kitchen? Here’s what you need to know:

Table of Contents show

Pick a Tile You Can Live With For Years To Come

While tile can be removed and new tile installed down the road, most of us want to choose a tile that we will love 10 years from now. If you’re dead set on something trendy, just know that you may not like it years from now. If you can live with that, then go for it!

I know that we will never plan on remodeling this kitchen again, so it was important to me that I chose a tile that would stand the test of time. While the honed marble I ultimately chose is not a budget-friendly choice (subway tile, on the other hand, is!), it is a classic that I know will stand the test of time.

Determine Your Style

Consider the overall style of your kitchen, including the color of your cabinets, countertops, and flooring. This will help you decide on the style and color of tile that will complement the rest of your kitchen.

Focal Point or Not?

Decide whether you want your backsplash to be a focal point in your kitchen or blend in with the rest of the design.

If you have simple cabinets and countertops, a bold backsplash can add interest to the space. However, if you have a lot of other patterns and textures in your kitchen, you may want to opt for a more subtle or neutral colors for your tile backsplash.

Tile Should Coordinate With Your Countertop Color

Choosing tile that coordinates and compliments your countertops is important for a few reasons. A mismatched backsplash can look tacky and unprofessional, like it’s there only because it was cheap.

white quartz counter tops, marble backsplash and white cabinets

You want to make sure your kitchen looks its best, so buy the most suitable material (tile, glass or marble) according to your tastes and budget.

When shopping around for materials have pictures in hand of different materials you like, then compare them with the current countertop. It will be hard to visualize how something new will work without actually being able to hold it in your hands and see what works together.

Do not buy your countertop and backsplash tile in isolation. I already had my heart set on these Bianco Carrara subway tiles from Floor & Decor, so I brought a sample with me when I was countertop shopping, along with a sample of my cabinets, too.

That way I was able to make sure that the countertop wasn’t too bright white or too creamy against the cooler tones of the tile and slightly warmer white of the cabinets.

If you are working in reverse (you already have a countertop or chose it first), then bring a sample tile shopping with you. If you can’t do this, narrow down your tile choices to 5 or 6, purchase a sample of each and bring it home to sample against your countertop.

Anything you don’t use can easily be returned (yes, even individual pieces!).

Tile Type

There are many types of tile that can be used for a kitchen backsplash, including ceramic tile, natural stone like marble, glass tile, or even opting for a slab of quartz or marble instead of traditional tiles.

Each has its pros and cons, so it’s important to consider your needs and budget. A simple subway tile can run at only 40 cents a piece, whereas more expensive tiles can be $30.00 a square foot.

Ceramic tile

Pros:

  • Affordable and available in a wide range of colors and patterns.
  • Easy to clean and maintain.
  • Resistant to water and heat.

Cons:

  • Not as durable as other types of tiles and can crack or chip easily.
  • May not be suitable for heavy use kitchens.
  • Grout lines can stain over time and require regular cleaning.

Natural stone tile (such as marble, granite, or slate)

Pros:

  • Unique and natural appearance with a wide range of colors and patterns.
  • Durable and long-lasting with proper care.
  • Heat and water-resistant.

Cons:

  • Expensive compared to other types of tiles.
  • Requires regular sealing and maintenance.
  • Some types of stone are porous and can stain easily.

Porcelain Tile

Pros:

  • Similar to ceramic tiles, but they are denser and more durable, making them an ideal choice for high-traffic areas like kitchens.
  • Water-resistant, which makes them easy to clean and maintain.
  • Resistant to stains and scratches

Cons:

  • Porcelain tile is a hard material, which can make it difficult to cut and install. This may require a professional installer.

Glass Mosaic Tiles

Pros:

  • Mosaic tiles are less popular now than they were 10 years ago.
  • Easy to clean and maintain.
  • Reflects light and can make the space appear larger.

Cons:

  • Expensive compared to other types of tiles.
  • Can be difficult to install due to the smaller size of the tiles.
  • May not be suitable for heavy use kitchens as it can scratch or chip.

Subway Tile

Pros:

  • Classic and timeless look that works well with different kitchen styles.
  • Available in a variety of colors and sizes.
  • Easy to install and maintain.
  • Also all the benefits of ceramic tile
  • Still one of the most popular options.

Cons:

  • Can appear boring or generic if not paired with the right design elements.
  • Grout lines can be difficult to clean and may require regular maintenance.
  • Limited in terms of design options compared to other types of tiles.

Stone Slab Backsplash (natural stone or quartz):

Pros:

  • Provides a seamless and luxurious look to the kitchen.
  • Popular choice in modern kitchens.
  • Durable and long-lasting with proper care.
  • Resistant to water and heat.

Cons:

  • Expensive compared to other types of tiles.
  • Requires professional installation.
  • Can be heavy and may require additional support.

Budget

It’s worth mentioning again but budget is a very practical consideration for most people. Backsplash tiles come in a wide range of prices, so it’s important to consider your budget when making a selection. Some backsplash materials, such as natural stone, can be quite expensive. Don’t be afraid to shop around!

Consider Maintenance

Finally, consider the maintenance required for the type of tile you choose. Some materials like natural stone require regular sealing, while others like ceramic are easier to maintain.

Don’t Forget to Consider Your Flooring

While the flooring isn’t nearly as important to match, since our new mudroom floor would be visible from the kitchen, I wanted it to flow and not look disjointed.

gray mudroom floor

For this reason I chose a simple large format gray tile with gray grout (the color “cobblestone” from Mapei). I It meshes well with the gray in the kitchen backsplash and is easily cleaned, since the mudroom is a high traffic area.

How To Calculate The Amount of Tile Needed

To calculate how much tile is needed for your kitchen backsplash, measure the width and height of the area where you want to install the tile. Multiply the width by the height to get the square footage, then add 10% to account for cuts and waste.

If you’re running the tile to the ceiling, don’t forget to account for the extra square footage.

The great thing about purchasing extra tile is that you’ll have it on hand so that you don’t need to run to the store for extra, AND almost all stores will take back any extra tile by the piece! So even if you only have a half a box left, you can return it!

Why I Chose Honed Marble Tile

Subway tile and Zellige tile seem are currently a popular choice of both homeowners and interior designgers for a tile backsplash. I think they are both beautiful. White subway tiles are inexpensive and always look good, and the natural variation and glazed finish of the Zellige tile adds more texture and interest than a basic subway.

However, I’m already sick of seeing these types of tiles on Instagram so I was worried that I was quickly tire of them in my own home, too.

Marble is considerably more expensive than subway tile (or many other tiles for that matter). But marble has been around for centuries and still looks beautiful to me. It has so much variation in each piece of tile and it works with the overall cooler color scheme I have in my home.

It’s also very durable, especially when sealed properly.

I shopped around a lot for larger marble subway tiles, and was happy to find the best price and selection at Floor & Decor. Whatever tile you have your heart set on, I bet you will find it there! It’s such an amazing store.

The Boxes of Tile Need to Be Mixed Prior to Installation

My only major caveat with marble is that because it’s a natural stone, there will be a lot of variation. The “white” carrara that I purchased has been sorted so that it’s generally on the lighter scale of grays. However, there’s definitely still some darker grays, some beiges and even tile with naturally occurring patterns that would have bothered me.

For the most natural look, the boxes of marble need to be mixed prior to being installed. This is really important to avoid sections that are darker and lighter – because the tile tends to be boxed similarly (you’ll find one box of all lighter, almost white tile and then another that’s all dark tile).

marble tile laid out to be installed on the kitchen wall

I was a bit extra, and went a step further, and hand-picked every single piece of tile that went up on the wall. I know from past experience that there’s nothing more annoying that one piece of marble that has a pattern like a face, or a wave or something weird, that will stick out like a sore thumb and bother me for eternity.

I also pulled out all the darker tiles that I didn’t like, as well as any that had a beige or slightly yellow/green cast to them.

How to Decide on a Grout Color

While choosing a grout color is partially dictated by the tile itself, it is also personal choice.

When I was ready to have my new honed marble backsplash installed, everyone told me to choose gray grout for easy cleaning and so that the marble would blend together, creating a more seamless feel.

However, I didn’t want a seamless feel and I love the look of white grout with Carrara marble. Yes, it creates more of a “picture frame” look (similar to white subway tile with darker grout) but I like that, and I like how the white grout stops the marble from ever looking too dark.

picking a grout color for the backsplash tile

I didn’t go into this blindly knowing what colors of grout to use, though. I made sure to do my homework and I worked with a store assistant at my local Floor & Decor store who helped me match my tile to a few suitable grout colors. Then we narrowed it down from there.

The best tip she gave me was to look at the colors in the tile itself. Those will dictate what grout colors will work best. In the case of my marble, I had white, light gray and darker gray. Any of those three colors made for the perfect grout compliment.

If you’re dealing with a plain white tile (like subway), you can choose whatever grout color you want. Just keep in mind, the darker the grout the less forgiving it is. Medium to dark gray grout will show every single minor imperfection and amplify it.

For those of you who need a bit more help beyond just choosing grout colors, Floor & Decor offer free design services.  Their designers can help you pick product and materials to help you finish the project. When renovating, every bit of free help is welcome, right?!

What’s The Best Grout Line Size for a Backsplash?

Your grout line size depends on the look you are trying to achieve and where it will be.

Smaller grout lines help tile blend more seamlessly and require less cleaning. My tile guy recommended 1/16 inch as what most people want for their backsplash, but after comparing it side by side with the 1/8 size, I opted for the slightly larger grout size. But that was totally a personal preference thing!

Larger grout lines on backsplashes are generally considered outdated, and should be reserved for flooring. For my pantry floor, I also chose the 1/8 size but up to 1/4 inch would have been fine. I wanted to keep the grout line relatively small, to avoid worrying out cleaning too much grout in the future!

How to Seal Marble Tiles

Marble has been around forever because it’s easy to clean, very durable and beautiful. However, marble is porous (especially the honed type that I chose) so it needs to be sealed to avoid stains.

Sealing is actually very easy to do and can be re-done every six to 12 months to keep your marble backsplash looking its very best. To seal your marble backsplash make sure to use an impregnating sealer that’s compatible with marble.

Frequently Asked Questions

The choice between a lighter or darker backsplash compared to your countertop depends on a variety of factors, including the mood you want to set, the visual focus you want to achieve, and the overall style of your kitchen. Here are some considerations for each option:

Lighter Backsplash:

  1. Bright and Open: A lighter backsplash can make a kitchen feel more open and airy.
  2. Highlight Features: If your countertop is a focal point and has unique features like an interesting grain, veining, or detailed craftsmanship, a lighter backsplash can draw attention to these elements.
  3. Versatility: Lighter tones are often easier to match with different colors and styles, offering more flexibility for future changes.
  4. Cautions: Lighter colors can show stains and grime more easily, so consider the cleaning aspect as well.

Darker Backsplash:

  1. Depth and Drama: A darker backsplash can add depth and a touch of drama to your kitchen, making it feel more enclosed but also cozier.
  2. Accent Wall: A darker backsplash can serve as an accent wall, creating a distinct focal point in your kitchen.
  3. Concealment: Darker colors are generally better at hiding stains and marks, which can be beneficial in a kitchen setting.
  4. Cautions: Too much darkness can make a space feel small and claustrophobic, so consider your kitchen’s size and the amount of natural light when going this route.

Balancing Act:

  1. Visual Weight: Consider the “visual weight” of each element. Dark colors are heavier visually and will draw more attention, while light colors will recede.
  2. Contrast: A high contrast between the backsplash and countertop can be striking but can also be busy, especially if both materials have complex patterns.
  3. Style Context: Your decision should also depend on the style of your kitchen (e.g., modern, traditional, eclectic) as well as other elements like wall color, cabinetry, and fixtures.

As an interior design guideline, there’s no hard and fast rule that says a backsplash must match any one specific element in the kitchen, such as the countertop, floor, or walls. The choice often depends on the overall design scheme, personal taste, and desired visual impact. Here are some general approaches to consider:

Matching the Countertop:

  1. Cohesive Look: If you prefer a uniform and cohesive look, matching the backsplash with the countertop is a safe bet. This is often seen in traditional designs.
  2. Material Consistency: Using the same material for both the countertop and backsplash, like marble or granite, can give a clean and seamless look.

Matching the Floor:

  1. Visual Continuity: Aligning the backsplash with the flooring can establish a strong visual line or flow in the space.
  2. Balance: If your flooring is distinctive and you want to draw attention to it, a matching backsplash can help maintain balance without overwhelming the space.

Matching the Walls:

  1. Expansion Effect: A backsplash that matches the wall color can make a kitchen appear larger and more open.
  2. Simplicity: If your walls are a neutral color, a matching backsplash can add to a minimalist and uncluttered look.

Contrasting Elements:

  1. Accent Piece: The backsplash can also serve as an accent or focal point, offering a pop of color or a unique pattern that contrasts with all other elements.
  2. Eclectic Taste: If you have a mix of styles and textures, a contrasting backsplash can add another layer of depth.

Porcelain, ceramic, and glass tile are the easiest types of backsplashes to clean because they resist staining, are naturally nonporous, and don’t require any special cleaning products. If you want to make your life really easy, a slab backsplash instead of individual tiles eliminates the need for grout, which makes cleaning even easier.

A light color backsplash that bounces and reflects light back into the room will make your kitchen look bigger. Conversely, a dark colored backsplash will absorb light and potentially make your kitchen look smaller.

Final Thoughts

I hope hearing about my process for selecting tile for my kitchen remodel was helpful for you! It was one of my favorite aspects of designing my new kitchen and I’m so thrilled with how it turned out.

At the end of the day, the best tile for a kitchen backsplash is one that works with the overall style of the kitchen and that meets your level of comfort in terms of cleaning ability and durability.

If you’re starting the process and trying to figure out how to choose a backsplash, visualizing everything together is key, so don’t be afraid to bring samples while choosing a kitchen color countertop, cabinets, and even paint colors.

More kitchen posts

Looking for more? Follow me on social media for lots more home decor & DIY content!

Pinterest | Instagram | Facebook | LTK

Jenna is a self taught decorator and lover of all things interior design who has helped thousands create a home they love.

Similar Posts