This post may contain affiliate links | For further details, please read our privacy policy

Learn more about Sherwin Williams Mindful Gray, including its undertones, how it compares to other popular grays, Repose Gray and Agreeable Gray, as well as color palettes that it works best with.

Sherwin Williams Mindful Gray in a dining room

You already know that most of my home is painted with Sherwin Williams Repose Gray and Benjamin Moore Stonington Gray. But one color that I frequently get asked about is the paint color in our dining room.

Those of you who have noted that it looks darker than the Repose Gray in the adjoining hallway are in fact, right. Our dining room is actually painted Sherwin Williams Mindful Gray, which is the next darkest shade on the same color card as Repose Gray.

Mindful Gray Undertones

Mindful Gray is a warm gray, with a green and sometimes taupe, undertone. The taupe is more evident in Repose Gray, while the green is more evident in Mindful Gray.

In a room dark room with not a lot of natural light, or a room with a lot of dark furniture, the green will become more apparent.

If you are using this paint color in a light-filled room, it will certainly look more like a warm gray.

Two comparisons: dark wooden table and tall wicker chairs on the left; same wooden table but with white upholstered chairs and a large, light blue rug

The above photo demonstrates my point. This is the same room, paint Mindful Gray. On the left, all the furniture is brown and it clearly brings out a green undertone on the back wall. On the right side of the photo, the chairs have been switched out for lighter ones, and a light colored rug has been added, which has eliminated the green undertone from the paint color.

These photos were also taken at different times of the day, from a room that is east-facing: so it gets nice morning light, but’s dark all afternoon. The darker photo was taken late in the day, while the brighter version was taken in the morning. Again, highlighting the importance of light when deciding on a paint color.

A corner of the dining room with a blackboard displaying chalk art and a side table with various decor items and extra plates/bowls

Look closely at this photo. The left side of the image is clearly darker, and the green undertone is apparent. Whereas in the top right hand side, it’s getting lovely natural light and looks closer to a neutral gray.

RELATED: The Best Paint Colors For Dark Rooms

Not only understanding undertones, but how they can be highlighted or reduced based on your furnishings (or even what’s outside the window) is important when selecting a paint color. I’ve had many people tell me that Mindful Gray has no undertones, that it’s the perfect saturated warm gray, but it’s simply not true for every situation.

Mindful Gray vs Repose Gray

A console table in the entryway, where the wall is painted with Mindful Gray, compared with a wall in the background, painted with Mindful Gray

If you are considering these two paint colors for your home, again, please consider your furnishings and other nearby colors.

Like I previously mentioned, lots of wood tones will bring out a strong green undertone in Mindful Gray but less so in Repose Gray.

I would consider Mindful Gray a medium-tone gray while Repose Gray is a medium to light gray with a warm undertone.

Repose Gray is actually my all-time favorite gray because it never feels cold, even in a room with a lot of cool white and cold light. While we have only used Mindful Gray in our dining room, our kitchen, entryway and landing are all painted Repose Gray.

Mindful Gray vs Agreeable Gray

If you are looking for a gray that’s got about the same depth as Mindful Gray but without so much of the green undertone, Sherwin Williams’ Agreeable Gray might be a better bet for you.

It’s a bit warmer than Mindful Gray, and can switch between being a “warm gray” or “greige” depending on the light. Besides that, it doesn’t have any funky undertones that you might be wary of, so it’s a great whole-house choice.

In fact, Agreeable Gray is regularly hailed as one of the best warm grays or greige paint colors out there.

Where to Avoid Using it

Personally, I do not love Mindful Gray in a darker spaces. If your room is east-facing, you will find that the paint color looks beautiful in morning like but a bit dark and muddy in the afternoon. Vice versa will apply in a western-exposure room, and a north facing room may feel a bit too dark throughout the day.

If your room benefits from multiple exposures, or primarily warm light, you really see how beautiful this paint color can be.

Ultimately, we repainted our East facing dining room in a much lighter color, Benjamin Moore Paper White, which has completely lightened and brightened the space, no matter what time of day it is.

Final Thoughts

Hopefully if you’ve been struggling to figure out if Sherwin Williams Mindful Gray is for you then this post will have been of some help to you! Remember to consider the possibility of a green undertone showing if you are painting a dark with with dark wood furnishings. By keeping the trim a bright white, and most of the surrounding furnishings lighter, you should be able to diminish most of that green.

If, on the other hand, you’re dealing with a light-filled room, you should not have any issues at all, and Mindful Gray will appear as a lovely warm gray.

Don’t Forget To Always Use Real Paint Samples!

Don’t forget – no matter what you’ve read or photos you’ve seen online, it’s really important to sample paint colors in your home before committing!

Samplize provides real paint samples that are easy to move around your home, and cheaper than buying a gazillion paint pots! It’s the only way I buy paint samples.

Use code JENNAK10 at checkout and get 10% off your order

Coupon entitles all customers to 10% off the entire order with no minimum purchase requirement. This is a one-time use coupon and it cannot be combined with other discounts.

Similar Posts


  1. Anne Tognelli says:

    Hi Jenna,

    I am doing a complete 1st floor renovation of living room and kitchen/dining area. The kitchen faces the east and afternoon sun comes through the dining room window located on the south side. There is also a sliding glass door that faces the east. This is all one room with a peninsula dividing both areas. The cabinetry in the kitchen is going to be white, with walnut flooring, stainless steel appliances and white trim. The counter top is white granite with gray veining, although the island will have a walnut top. The living room will also have the walnut flooring. The living room has one window that faces the south and the 2 front windows that face the west. I am leaning towards using Repose Gray on all walls (Silverpointe might also be a contender). What do you think? Additionally, there is a powder room off the kitchen that has no windows. The flooring will be a gray tile. Not sure what to use for wall color here. Should it be lighter? Lastly, I will also be having the stairway leading upstairs painted where there is a rather sizable landing area with bookshelves (no windows), not sure what to do here for a gray. I appreciate your input….all these grays are driving me crazy. Thank you!

    1. Specific decorating questions will no longer be answered in the comments section. Please direct your question to our Decorating Facebook Group. Thank you!

  2. Nancy Smith says:

    I would like to use a gray color in my living room, dining room/kitchen, hall, master bedroom and master bath. None of these areas receive much natural light. I have only two windows in each with white wooden plantation shutters on all. There is a cathedral ceiling in the living room. I have tiles floors that are combination of light and dark beige/tan/sand/ medium gray. Grout is color of wet sand. Is there a gray that won’t make the rooms look even darker?
    Thanks for your time.
    Nancy Smith
    Aiken, SC

    1. Hi Nancy, in the darker rooms in my home, I always opt for BM Paper White. It’s a very very light dove gray and instantly brightens a space while still looking gray.

  3. I’m remodeling a bathroom and thinking of painting the cabinets either repose gray or mindful. would Ben Moore paperwhite be a good choice for the walls?, with crisp white trim? Or maybe agreeable gray for cabinets?

    1. I would probably go with the darker colors mindful or agreeable for the cabinets for more contrast but Paperwhite with white trim would be perfect on the walls

  4. Hi Jenna,

    We are planning Repose Gray in our open living space with kitchen in it and we have Gray cabinets.
    Could you please tell if these 2 go well.

    Thanks !!

  5. I am trying to get away from all the beige in my house. I have a brown sectional couch, which I will need to keep. Would mindful gray or repose gray go better with the gray couch?

  6. Jocelyne Bricker says:

    We are thinking of painting our house Repose grey in the bedrooms and bathrooms and mindful grey in our family room and kitchen and a home depot Greige for an accent wall for a darker contrast. We will be painting our kitchen cabinets a grey color and we are struggling with that color. we don’t want too much blue undertones. we picked a SW galveston but it is too close to the Mindful grey. and another one is Dunn Edwards Steiglitz. Can you recommend colors please.

    1. Hi Jocelyne. It’s hard to tell without seeing the space. With gray walls in your kitchen, gray cabinets would not be my first choice as that will be a lot of gray. If you are definitely set on gray cabinets though, I would make sure there’s enough contrast. You’re not going to want anything close to Repose Gray…you’ll want either an almost white gray (like Paper White, maybe even lightened a smidge) or something significantly darker like BM Amherst Gray.

    2. Melissa G. says:

      I came across this post via Pinterest while looking for others thoughts on Mindful Gray. I painted our living room in MG based off of everyone saying it was a beautiful midtoned neutral. Ever since I painted it all I can see is the green undertones in the evening. 😬 Our LR is North East facing with a lot of midtoned wood pieces (mcm wood color) and a cognac leather couch. It has more windows on the East side. It looks perfect in the morning, but by afternoon it’s a dark green muddy mess. I’m glad to finally find someone else who sees this, too!!!
      I’m currently trying to find the perfect color to repaint it, but MG has made me leary and I second guess everything. 😅 But, now at least I feel validated in the green undertones I kept seeing in MG! 😂 I’ve decided to lighten it up a lot with an off white with greige undertones. I have a cognac leather couch and mid toned greige/gray curtains I’d love to keep. So, I think a white with a greige undertone will marry them well. Thoughts?

      1. Haha yes it can be REALLY green and muddy! Try A few samples: I recommend SW repose gray or repose gray lightened by 50%. It’s my absolute favorite paint color and works everywhere. Another great choice is BM paper white

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *